Monday, September 27, 2010

Seen

Echo Eggebrecht : Spells, Spoils & Lucky Charms : Sep 11 – Oct 9, 2010
11 p.m.

2010
Oil on panel
25x29" / 63.5x73.6cm
EE009
11 p.m.

Toast

2010
Oil on panel
24x32" / 60.9x81.2cm
EE010
Toast

Year One

2010
Oil on panel
24x30" / 60.9x76.2cm
EE012
Year One

Bright Blessed Days, Dark Sacred Nights

2010
Oil on panel
24x30" / 60.9x76.2cm
EE008
Bright Blessed Days, Dark Sacred Nights

 


Wednesday, September 22, 2010

Seen

Caravaggio’s Entombment and a Copy and Reinterpretation by Rubens
                                                                                                         
 Caravagio 1602-03 Pinacoteca, Vatican    






Rubens 1611-12 National Gallery of Canada, Ottawa









TITIEN The Entombment of Christ c. 1520 Louvre
In 1611-12 Rubens painted a copy of Caravaggio’s Entombment. While it is a relatively close copy, there are some telling differences. The Caravaggio original is striking. Caravaggio takes a low vantage point, as the participants in the drama huddle near the edge of the abyss of the tomb. Christ, dead and pale is held under the back by John, and at the knees by Nicodemas, in a pose somewhat reminiscent, reversed, of the 1520 Titian Entombment now in the Louvre, cradled in a white cloth while his arm hangs down limp. While Titian shrouds the head of Christ in deep shadow, adding to a sense of mystery, Caravaggio illuminates the full body in divine but unflinching light; Christ is a body and he is dead. Titian paraded his figures before us, parallel to the picture plane, grounded in a gloomy but realistic landscape. Caravaggio turned the scene almost 45 degree, with Christ’s feet toward the viewer and his body angling back into space. Any hint of the landscape is lost in shadow, as the figures bunch up to the edge of the tomb slab in a compact, theatrical tableau. As sometimes happens in Caravaggio’s work, the piling up of figures, while initially convincing, upon reflection defies logic; there hardly seems to be enough room on the marble slab for the five (six?) standing figures. Mother Mary seems to merge into Mary Magdalene like Siamese twins, while the mother’s right hand reaches beyond John to hover above Christ’s head; Mary of Cleaophas’s right hand, meanwhile, rises above the entire group, almost too large for the body it is supposed to be attached to, while her left arm seems compress somewhat awkwardly to fit within the picture frame. In addition, they are pressed forward to be illuminated by the common light, but their relative scales seem off; Nichodemus, bent over while holding Christ at the knees would likely tower over the three Marys behind him if he stood up; Christ himself would seem to be too large for the entire group, and would likely tower over even Nicholdemus if he was to stand erect (this may also be true of the Titan version. Some day, computer modeling may perhaps resolve some of these complex questions of proportion and perspective.) None of these issues necessarily detract from the painting’s overall effect: Christ is the dominant figure in the story and the painting, and the overall scene is believable in its solemn grandeur. The figures are large, monumental and sculptural, as we are watching a moment that is both common and epic at the same time. The body of Christ is without question dead. One can see the discoloration of death already overtaking the head and extremities; the right arm hangs down lifeless, almost out of control, as dead matter. The torso had the weight of dead flesh, Nichodemus bundles the legs in both arms for additional support; his bent posture and the awkward extension of his elbow into space again emphasizes the weight of the dead body, the presence of Christ as dead human flesh.
This, of course is one of the main revolutionary techniques of Caravaggio, the blending of the sacred with the commonplace. As much as other artists since Giotto may have grounded the divine story in solid three dimensional forms in a believable and logical landscape, and may have even introduced commonplace models for secondary figures, the divine protagonists remained idealized and ethereal, not quite of this earthly world. Common actors may look on to the manger scenes in Botticelli or Correggio, but the holy family remained beautiful, ideal, divine. Viewing a Caravaggio, a man from the Renaissance might not at first recognize the highly religious story-telling going on. Caravaggio’s world is one of peasants with dirty feet, of saints whose ink-stained hands who must be physically guided by angelic inspiration, a world of darkened taverns, where miracles occur with the unexpectedness of light flooding in from open doors. For it is the light: that is Caravaggio’s great metaphor: the light is divine. It is the signifier of God, the chosen are highlighted by it. There is a silence in the light of Caravaggio, of even violent moments stilled to a hush by clear divine light. In the Entombment, Christ is the figure fully lit, fully in the rapture of divine light, even in death. all else is darkness.
             So beneath the seemingly simple picture several things are going on. There is the bringing down to the earthy plane the divine story as a visual illustration of the notion of Christ’s humanity. Simultaneously, using light as a signifier of the divine, falling upon the human, earthly form with the believable similitude of nature; combining in one form the two half’s of the Christian doctrine that Christ was both sacred and divine simultaneously. First there is the human drama of the movement and burial of a dead human body, and the basic sadness and grief we all feel instinctually for the passing of our fellow humans, followed by the realization of the divine nature of the story being told, and the immense importance of the moment for the believers in Christian myth. This is the lowest moment in all of Christianity: Christ has suffered and has died. All the miracles seem to be behind him, now, as well as the pacific endurance of torture and cruel death, and the abandonment of the mortal coils. For now he is neither divine nor fully human, he is only dead flesh, and that dead flesh is to be disposed of like any other, with the reverence befitting the life lived and the flesh and suffering endured. The greatest miracle of the Christian faith is two days away, unknown at this moment to this scene’s participants. At this moment, for them, the Christian era is over, the story is at an end; they do not know that story will begin again in two days time, and provide a whole new basis for interpretation of the mortal human life of Christ by proving without doubt his divinity. At this moment, they mourn him as a man, as proven by his dead flesh.
Flesh, then is key to the story and our understanding of it; the entombment theme is a key to the mythology in its emphasis on Christ’s mortality, and the humanity and suffering of the other actors, especially Mary. In Caravaggio’s version, Mary is downplayed. She remains an almost indistinguishable shadow of enclosed suffering. Magdalene is more prominent, though again hidden somewhat in shadow, enclosed with her raised hand in silent weeping. In Caravaggio’s version, the emphasis is all on Christ; his large, lifeless flesh. It is almost his last moment in the earthly realm, the moment before being lowered into the tomb, the last moments when anyone will see him as human flesh; the next time he is seen he will have crossed over into the divine, he will be a God beyond dispute.
             (Even then Caravaggio emphasizes the divine through flesh, for Christ does not come back to his followers as an animal, or an apparition or as a burning bush, but as the body of Christ, triumphed over death. It is something beyond belief, or too incredible to be believed, so Christ must prove to Thomas by guiding his finger into his wound to prove to both Thomas and to us that it is both real and miraculous: it is flesh, and yet he has triumphed over flesh and become divine.) The viewers of entombment pictures know the miracle of the resurrection to come, but know too that Christ must pass through these stages of human death like any other man. If Christ had miraculously ascended into heaven directly from the cross, it would have been a less satisfying miracle; for he is given a proper burial, after a cruel and ignominious death; his human existence is honored by proper ritual; this is the moment of greatest homage to humanity. His resurrection is more than an out-of-body embrace of the finality of death, it is an actual re-animation of dead flesh, an actual triumph over physical matter.
               Caravaggio would seem an artist uniquely suited to address questions of the flesh. His stark realism and lack of overtly idealized form redefined what was permissible pictorial reality. For Caravaggio, all of physical reality was worthy of depiction. More than that, the realism of his paintings was a re-affirmation of the humanity embodied by Christ, of the divine presence that coexisted in the earthly realm, and thus the moral hope for immortality amoungst mortal men. For Caravaggio was almost exclusively a religious painter; after a period in his early career painting still lives and young boys in various states of undress, or card players or musicians, his subjects throughout his mature career is almost entirely of Christian religious nature. While some of this may be attributable to the patrons and commissions available to him, there is very little portraiture in his ouvure, and little if any pagan themes in his work, unlike his contemporary Carracci, who returned again and again to classical themes and mythology. There is no “Birth of Venus” in Carravaggio’s work, no reclining female nudes in classical landscapes, or battles of Greek gods or heroic exploits of ancient heros. One must assume that Carravaggio was a serious believer in the Christian faith, despite biographical details of his life so widely known. As an artist, he has consistently depicted moments of Christian calling and rapture. He has set up the difficult task of depicting somehow what cannot be seen—the divine interactions of God with man, not just the physical manifestations or prostrations of that interaction, but the inner workings of the soul in reaction to it. Light, then, is the messenger of God. But like God, the source of the light it almost always hidden, it shines down on St Paul with quiet, miraculous clarity; it rakes in from the right in the calling of Matthew, like a siren calling to what it seeks. It is a subtle technique, that works on an emotional, basic level. We sense the rapture in Paul’s mind as he lies beneath his horse, arms upraised; we sense that moment of surprise and recognition at Emaus, when the dead but ressurected Christ is recognized. Despite the reputation for violence in his work, few pictures depict actual violence; more often, there are quiet, solemn moments of conversion and pathos.

The 1610 copy by Rubens shows some interesting variations on the Caravaggio original. The main figure of Christ is almost identical, except for the head which in Rubens’ falls back limp more believably as dead flesh. John has shifted a step forward around Christ’s head to better support his dead weight, while his own shadowed head hovers just above Christ’s own, creating an intense intimacy between living and dead. Nichodemus is in basically the same attitude, though not quite as hunched as in Carravaggios; rather than looking out of the scene toward the viewer, Nichodemus, head slightly more elevated, looks across to the dead Christ with a mournful gaze. His raised head, however, almost completely covers mother Mary, whose is only visible as a draped head. John’s moving forward to the head of Christ has also left a slightly awkward gap that had been filled with the red drape in the Caravaggio. Rubens fills it with the rest of the white burial shroud that sweeps up from Christ’s left shoulder to Nichodemus right shoulder. Possibly Nichodemus had used it over his shoulder as a sling, to bear the weight of the dead body. In the present configuration, the drape acts almost as an arrow to Christs’ head, connecting the standing group behind to his supine figure. Nichodemus too has changed from a red/orange garment to blue, while John is all in red now, creating a redish hot spot around the head of Christ. Caravagio had isolated the head of Christ against the back background, emphasized by Mary’s hand some distance above it, filling in for a halo; isolated against the black beyond, almost as if heading into the blackness of the sarcophagus and what is thought to be the eternal darkness of death. Rubens shows actually less of the head of Christ, due to its obtuse angle and tilt back, but it is almost more visible, the eye drawn there by the sweep of the shroud and the red of John’s garment.
Most striking of all, Rubens has moved Mary of  Claephas, whose raised arms in the right rear of the Caravaggio picture is a dramatic link between the human and the divine; her gesture is a cry of human suffering, for suffering that is beyond words, and yet bathed in an indescribable light too bright for moonlight, but too dark for day gives recognition that she is in the presence of the divine both seen, in the dead form of Christ and unseen in the source of the light; it is a gesture straight out of Caravaggio’s own conversion of St Paul, the bridge between the physical and the supernatural. One’s eyes move around the Caravagio in a wide circle between Mary of  Claephas, then ignorant of the approaching miraculous resurrection, as a stand-in through her dramatic gesture of upraised hands for despairing humanity, and the dead Christ, not yet divine. It is this play between the human gesture toward the heavens with the opposing gesture of Christ’s limp arm pointing downward that contributes to the dramatic tension of painting. The role reversal of these gestures--humans seeking the divine, the Gods pointing earth-ward--place the drama in the center of human longing for salvation, for divinity. 
Rubens all but eliminates Mary of  Claephas, lowers her hands and moves her forward to in front of mother Mary, barely visible as a weeping head within the darkness, shifting the emphasis back onto the dead Christ as dead flesh; gone is the dramatic appeal to the divine through upraised hands. As part of a tightly knit group of heads from Nichodemus to mother Mary to John to Christ, they form a tight circle that again leads to Christ, but brought closer to physical proximity and intensity; the limp head of the dead Christ leaning back adds a chilling drama to this tight group of attentive mourning heads. Christ remains the psychological center of the group and the object of everyone’s attention.
Only Magdeline does Rubens keeps almost exactly as Caravaggio depicted her, head down hand raised to her head quietly weeping. With Mary of Cleaophus moved forward, Magdeline stands alone behind the main group, isolated, surrounded by blackness. With the removal of Mary’s upraised arms, there is a much larger dark area above and to the right, with a barely perceptible figure lurching in the deep smokey shadows—attending of the tombs of some sort? In fact the whole scene is lowered slightly but the the abyss of the empty tomb looms large before them. With the blackness to the right of them and behind, this is a tight group, engrossed in their own private yet divine psycho-drama.
Rubens is a fascinating heir to the enormous innovations of Caravaggio. Both a consummate realist and an edifying idealist, Rubens with his immense natural gifts moved freely in both the earthly and the mythological worlds and was as comfortable depicting Greek myths and Christian mysteries as he was his own daughter or his young second wife clad only in furs. For Rubens, even more than Caravaggio, flesh was divine. A master of textures of all types, from furs to textiles to silks and rocks and foliage, it was human flesh which was Rubens’ greatest love. Few painters before or since have celebrated as Ruebns did the glories of the human flesh, in all its colorful nuance, from the glowing pearly bodies of his female nudes to the tanned arms of workers and shepherds, to the aged skin of elder prophets; every dimple of fat, every green vein just below the surface of the skin, every pinkish highlight and wisp of hair; all were glorious in Rubens’ eyes, all were the embodiment of the divine on earth. For Rubens was the consumatet humanist. Like Michelangelo before him, Rubens saw humans as imbued with divine energy and power. With his vibrant, fluid brushwork,  Rubens made flesh in motion and alive; all is motion and energy, nothing is static or frozen. While Caravaggio shows us specific moments, often moments of adulation and action, there is also a certain stillness and silence in Caravaggio, of action that is at its moment of peak, a momentary pause before falling back into repose again, but a supreme moment, a climax. For Rubens there are moments of climax but more often as a moment in an ongoing series of moments, a continuum of action; even figures resting in Rubens seem restless, their chests rising and falling with heavy breathing, the limbs ready for unconscious motion. For to be alive is to be active for Rubens, the flesh is vibrant, alive, the life force imbued by god. Is this a superficial attachment to surface appearance? For Rubens, man is an active agent, a life force.
While Caravaggio shows the slow discoloration of the limbs as Christ’s fingers touch the edge of the burial slab, Rubens mimics the same position, but Christ’s forearms are tanned and dark from the sun, (just as Nichodemus’ legs are noticeably more tanned in Ruben’s version) while his usually clothed torso is white, slightly more muscular, with greater potential for action, while as completely dead. The head of Caravaggio’s Christ, more visible, is almost shocking in it grey death mask; the head of Christ in Rubens falls back—even in death there is movement.
This was to be common in one of Rubens early major masterworks, painted a few years after his copy of the Caravaggio: his Antwerp Deposition:
               The dead body of Christ, released from the cross, falls lifeless in the hand of his bearers; even in death, there is movement of the body; the potentiality of action in the body—of self moment—is noticeable by its opposite, the depiction of the body as dead matter, athletic, vibrant, but as captive to the laws of gravity as any inanimate object; the loss of life is highlighted; Christ’s beauty and physical strength is contrasted with the awkward contortions of the twisted limbs, as they struggle to control and catch him.
  
  




The Descent from the Cross. 1611-1614..Cathedral, Antwerp, Belgium.
   
 




1615-1616 Courtauld Institute of Art Gallery, London
In 1615 Ruebns painted a kind of sequel to the Cravaggio Entombment. It is unclear exactly why and for whom this modest-sized painting was executed. Possibly it was a study for Rubens alone. We may also speculate that a year after completing the huge descent from the cross for the cathedral in Antwerp Rubens felt the urge to revisit the entombment scene he had copied earlier. It is an extraordinary sequel. It is as if he has taken a step forward in time and a step back in space: the scene is basically the same as in the Caravaggio entombment, the edge of the slab above the actual tomb, the close cluster of mourning figures. But here Rubens imagines the difficulty of handling the dead body and lovering it down into the tomb, just as in his Antewrp deposition he tried to imagine the difficulty of removing the dead body from the cross. In many ways, the Courtauld picture is a further investigation of the decent from the cross theme, grafted on to Caravagio’s model. While the Antwerp picture retains a level of elegance amid the complex array of figures, the Courtauld painting shows an awkward moment; it appears as if Nichodemus and John are almost at risk of dropping the dead body of Christ. Nichodeumus struggling and straining, his foot half over the edge of the slab, gripping one end of the burial cloth between his teeth, as in the Antwerp picture; Christ’s torso, and we assume the bulk of his dead weight is beyond the edge of the slab; the attendant, somewhat off-balance, raises his right leg to try to catch the body before it falls to the ground with a thud. The tension between Nichodemus and the lower attendant struggling with the body is palpable; John seems to have only a slight grip on Christ’s left shoulder, but as the body sinks down into space, John uses Christ’s left arm to help lower him down, while at the same time creating one last, if involuntary, gesture by Christ back up to mother Mary. With John lowered down as Christ is lowered, Mary’s gesture reaching out toward her dead son is exposed, while at the same time Mary of Cleophis gently holds mother Mary back with a hand on her chest. Here mother Mary takes a more prominent place in the drama, where she had been almost hidden in the Carravagio and first Rubens version. Rubens adds a second (?) Magdeline kissing Christ’s feet, again as in the Antwerp decent this time as a final parting gesture. 
What is striking about this Rubens “sequel” is the focus on the reactions of the observers rather than on the dead Christ; for this is without doubt the corporeal Christ, a limp and lifeless body. There is no indication of the divinity of Christ. The viewer of the painting is assumed to know this, but is not told; indeed, it is this fore-knowledge of Christ’s divine nature that makes his depiction here so shocking: for seldom has his human vulnerability been revealed in such stark terms, with no hint of the miracle that lay ahead. It was in this Baroque era which saw the culmination of the long march of increasingly humanizing images of Christ. In the roughly 800 years since the end of the Iconoclastic attacks on depictions of Christ, there had been a steady growth in naturalistic depictions of biblical scenes, as artists regained the skills of volumetric rendering and perspective in the centuries we label the Renaissance. The passion of Christ--his torture, death and resurrection--had by Rubens’ day been a long-established subject for artists. This had been one of the central themes of religious art for as many centuries. Before the Iconoclastic attack on images, Christ had been more often depicted in the youthful guise of a shepherd; having adopted some aspects of Bacchus imagery without its licentious content, the focus had been been on growth (via his resurrection in the spring;) He had already been associated with wine, through the miracle at Cana, but there had been a marked shift after iconoclastic persecutions ended in the 800s to more somber scenes of the torture and death of Christ, scenes that “all could agree on” as distinctly Christian in content that could not be mis-read as pagan. How much of this shift may be attributed to the series of gruesome plagues, wars and the other disruptions of the ensuing years is open for debate. It was the counter-reformation led pictorially by Carravagio that saw the trend toward the humanization of the Christian tale come to full fruition. Indeed, it was possibly only Rembrandt who took this to its culmination, again, under the influence of Carravagio.
Part of what is shocking about the Rubens sequel is his lifelong love of flesh; seldom has there been an artist as enthralled by living flesh as him. Dead flesh, so brutal and seemingly final as depicted here--flesh as dead weight--is a compound tragedy. Secretly, viewing this somber scene, we long to be able to overcome this moment, as all human do their own death; here is Christ at the ultimate moment of his humanity, as dead flesh, and at the same time already beyond human by being simply that--dead flesh. Yet, it is the belief in Christ, in the mind of the believer, that is the way to overcome death; for Christ did overcome his own death, and we can likewise through belief. But we do not see that triumph here, nor the barest hint of it. Here in this scene is the edge of absolute un-belief, of a finality of human mortality; we believe in the story not yet told here, what is to come, and the promise it holds; the alternative would be this--the eternal human crypt. We suspect that for Rubens--lover of flesh as he was--this had been somewhat painful to depict, though he did not shy away from it. Possibly the mythological aspect of the Christian passion, with its strong narrative drive allowed a certain abstraction and universalizing impulse which gave the life of Christ from birth to death to resurrection its endless appeal for the artist. The narrative arc from god (conceived miraculously through virgin birth) to human to god (the resurrection) is a perfect narrative or an artist with Rubens’ skill to be able to blend the ideal with the real, to depict the ideal with such fluid and seemingly effortless realism as to seem real.
Is Rubens too much in love with the flesh, at the expense of the divine? Probably this is the wrong question, since there is no evidence that Rubens saw a distinction between the two. His work in some ways can be interpreted as the artistic embodiment of the fundamental Christian notion of transubstantiation, for the reality Rubens creates is so vibrant as to be ideal, i.e divine. Carravaggio’s work is the more extreme in the realist direction: there is often little besides the signifying light to recommend his figures as divine. Rubens figures, idealized in the Renaissance manner, without the mannerist grotesque, had a vitality of realist execution which, through his immense skill as a craftsman he was able to balance convincingly. Jesus was a god who spoke like a human; in Rubens world, humans speak like gods. 
Based upon the often contradictory evidence in the gospels, Jesus seems to have had an ambivalent relationship with his own flesh and the flesh of others. While his embodiment in human flesh is the central element of his appointed role, he reminds his followers and others repeatedly of his divinity. Not only does he claim to be the son of god, he denies any distinction between the son and the father, while denying that god himself is made of the same flesh. His string of miracles--from curing various ailments such as leprosy, deafness, blindness, even death, to multiplying fishes or bread or wine to satiate his hungry followers--reflect more a desire to overcome the flesh than to embrace it. Human flesh is weak, and human existence is frail and vulnerable. The ultimate reward that Jesus offers those who believe in him is the ultimate triumph over human mortality. But there are a mass of contradictions; Christ reminds his followers that the kingdom of god is within them, and suggests that the resurrection of the flash is  simply a metaphor for the more abstract notion of unity with the absolute, while at the same time demonstrating his divinity by curing those who believe in him of their physical   ailments. This tension between the flesh and the divine runs through all the gospel narratives. While Christ preaches a certain moral life-style and way of treating our fellow-men, ultimate salvation rests on the belief in Christ’s divinity; to a Christian, this may not be any contradiction, since Christ’s divinity rests equally on his moral precepts as well as his physical embodiment in human form and his subsequent torture and death (and subsequent miraculous resurrection.) But the basic question of how literally we are to take his humanity remains; unlike Greek and Roman gods, who often started as humans and then became divine, Christ reminds us repeatedly in the gospels that his case was the opposite: he had been divine and had assumed human form for our benefit; in the end he would return to his divine nature, but he would leave no doubt as to his divine nature. It was his insistence of his divine nature, as well as his refusal to follow the established traditions of religious (Jewish) customs that seemed to be the greatest source of controversy among the religious leaders who were his contemporaries. But was this assuming of human form his greatest metaphor--to tell humanity that they too can become divine, (by following him--his moral preaching, namely to love god firstly and to love others.)
Why then did Christ have to die? Why so passively submit to a brutal death, if only to prove his divinity by overcoming it? Oddly, here is where Christianity aligns with one of Buddhism’s basic concepts: to exist is to suffer. Christ, to prove his humanity, must suffer physically, even unto death, as the ultimate empathic gesture of solidarity with man. (There are very few hints if any, of Christ enjoying his mortal coils; at one point, female followers oil his hair, and Christ obviously enjoys it, rebuking a disciple who says the money for the oil would be better spent feeding the poor with the curt retort that the poor will always be there, but Christ’s time was short; in  another instance, Christ seems to enjoy having his feet washed, again by women, and, like the oil, as a sign of respect as well as for the physical comfort it affords.) 
JC  demonstrated few human characteristics beyond his physical form. While he did take pity on human suffering when he saw it, and cured ailments when asked, more often this was as a test of the victim's belief; he seemed burdened by the crowds that followed him, and he fed them miraculously with scant resources, but still seemed fatigued by his own fame. As he was dismissive of religious convention, he was also dismissive of pre-existing human attachments; when fishermen say they must get back to their families, JC forcefully frees them from any familial obligation, insisting that they follow only him, as a representative of god. Likewise, he quite famously (and some would say cruelly) denies his own mortal mother, insisting he is only the son of both man generally and god specifically (but curiously not her.)
He himself, however, did not change,  never demonstrated human doubt, growth, humor or uncertainty. In this he is quite different from the Buddha, whose story encompasses trial and error, growth and learning on the way to ultimate self-fulfillment. Granted, the narrative present to us in the gospels is of a narrow time-frame; for the most part we have no notions of the first 30 years of Christ's life, and his path to maturity. The Christ presented to us is basically infallible and self-assured and self-confident, unwilling to concede anything to the scholars and priests of current religious tradition. Physiologically, Christ is an enigma, wrapped in the kind of obscurity that characterizes his parables. While he foretells his own death, this foreknowledge seem to give him a sense of dread at his corporeal embodiment; there is little if any appreciation for any fleshly pleasure--food, sleep or otherwise. Nature is almost entirely absent form the narrative, except for the sea, which exists as a dangerous advisory to be tamed by belief in god.
          Christ's humanity, then is almost solely of the flesh, rather than mental or spiritual; the flesh exists for him to be tortured and killed (as a proof of his humanity). Flesh, then, is the key.
The Courtland work is obviously a study, and it is unclear why it was created. Possibly there were some artistic ideas presented in the Caravagio original that Rubens felt he wanted to follow up on. Artists were for the most part subject to commissions for large finished works; Caravaggio was never given the opportunity to paint a resurrection; the miracle pending at the heart of the entombment is implied without being illustrated. If the Rubens Cortland was a private exercise for Rubens alone, he was under no contractual obligation to conform to any known iconographic or artistic language. Even if merely an excursive, however, it does demonstrate Ruben's fascination with the flesh as the embodiment of the divine. 
Christ himself, as god as well as man, foretold his own death, knew of course his own physical demise and the physical resurrection to come; for the resurrection was physical, and did involve the re-animation of dead flesh. Only later, at the transfiguration and assent-ion, does the physical cross over into pure spirit and loose its mortal coils. Where then is christ the god during the hours between his death on the cross late Friday and his physical resurrection on late Saturday or Sunday? Has the god Christ gone back to god the father in heaven awaiting the resurrection of the flesh, or is Christ truly dead in this period, awaiting the spark of re-animation by god? 
Again, these are some of the basic contradictions of the incarnation doctrine at the center of the Christian doctrine; these are likely un-resolvable questions that can only be answered by faith, and cannot be reconciled by reason. In the mind of the believer, the story resolves into an emotionally satisfying whole that cannot be fully grasped by those that do not share this belief. 
Art, like religion, works in that comparable area between flesh and idea, reason and emotion, and believer or unbeliever can have an emotional and intellectual response to artworks on a variety of levels. Great art like that of Caravagio and Rubens can stimulate both thought and emotion, which is itself another form of thinking. As the 17th century biographer and antiquarian noted  in reference to another keystone of Baroque painting--Carracci’s Farnesse ceiling--” the images require an attentive and ingenious viewer whose judgement resides not in his or her eyes but rather in the intellect. Certainly the mind will not be content with what it takes in at a glance. Rather it will remain to understand the mute eloquence of colors, since painting possesses such power that it is not confined to the eyes but through contemplation diffuses through the mind.”
Art--even the most retinal, painting--has always been conceptual. At the same time it can be also gloriously physical, sensual and emotional, and the best practitioners of the art of painting, Caravaggio and Rubens among them, create works that straddle that intriguing psychic purgatory between the eye and the mind.