Thursday, April 16, 2015

Read








“If there is a hell in wait for us, I know what one of the most fiendish torments will be: they will shut up the naked soul in a room with the framed photographs of his day: Quick, turn on the pathos: O man amid snapshots, passport photos. O man beneath the glare of flash bulbs, O man standing erect by the leaning tower of Pisa, O photomaton man who must expose his right ear if he is to be worthy of a passport! And—off with the pathos. Maybe this hell will be tolerable because the worst pictures of all are not taken but only dreamed or, if they are taken, never developed.”
Grass, Tin Drum, P46

Wednesday, April 15, 2015

Seen





Image result for creation of adam


In his most iconic representation the first human lies fully formed, in mature, virile, though recumbent perfection. He possesses strength enough only to stretch out his hand to receive the spark of life from the hand of his divine creator. His toned muscles await only this initial charge to spring into full action.


            This is not a representation of a specific moment, frozen in time like a photograph or a movie still, but rather an abstract, symbolic representation of an idea of creation. It presents a visual illustration of the idea of the transition from lifelessness to life. The first human defies specific categorization; his exact biological age is somewhat indeterminate, though he is beyond adolescence and has an almost athletic build of musculature; one guesses he is in his twenties, but he is abstracted as the “every man” at the peak of his physical powers though without specific age. He is mythical man, in mythical time, not the ordinary man with a life expectancy of 6-8 decades. He is an idea.


            This representation is consistent with Biblical texts describing the creation of the first humans. Though there is much ambiguity in the text, this visualization captures its literal description with impressive pictorial imagination.


            There are two versions of the creation of humans in the first 2 chapters of the Bible. Version 1:


 


[1:20] And God said, "Let the waters bring forth swarms of living creatures, and let birds fly above the earth across the dome of the sky."
[1:21] So God created the great sea monsters and every living creature that moves, of every kind, with which the waters swarm, and every winged bird of every kind. And God saw that it was good.
[1:22] God blessed them, saying, "Be fruitful and multiply and fill the waters in the seas, and let birds multiply on the earth."
[1:23] And there was evening and there was morning, the fifth day.
[1:24] And God said, "Let the earth bring forth living creatures of every kind: cattle and creeping things and wild animals of the earth of every kind." And it was so.
[1:25] God made the wild animals of the earth of every kind, and the cattle of every kind, and everything that creeps upon the ground of every kind. And God saw that it was good.



[1:26] Then God said, "Let us make humankind in our image, according to our likeness; and let them have dominion over the fish of the sea, and over the birds of the air, and over the cattle, and over all the wild animals of the earth, and over every creeping thing that creeps upon the earth."
[1:27] So God created humankind in his image, in the image of God he created them; male and female he created them.
[1:28] God blessed them, and God said to them, "Be fruitful and multiply, and fill the earth and subdue it; and have dominion over the fish of the sea and over the birds of the air and over every living thing that moves upon the earth."
[1:29] God said, "See, I have given you every plant yielding seed that is upon the face of all the earth, and every tree with seed in its fruit; you shall have them for food.
[1:30] And to every beast of the earth, and to every bird of the air, and to everything that creeps on the earth, everything that has the breath of life, I have given every green plant for food." And it was so.


[1:31] God saw everything that he had made, and indeed, it was very good. And there was evening and there was morning, the sixth day.
 


Followed by version 2:


 [2:1] Thus the heavens and the earth were finished, and all their multitude.
[2:2] And on the seventh day God finished the work that he had done, and he rested on the seventh day from all the work that he had done.
[2:3] So God blessed the seventh day and hallowed it, because on it God rested from all the work that he had done in creation.
[2:4] These are the generations of the heavens and the earth when they were created. In the day that the LORD God made the earth and the heavens,
[2:5] when no plant of the field was yet in the earth and no herb of the field had yet sprung up - for the LORD God had not caused it to rain upon the earth, and there was no one to till the ground;
[2:6] but a stream would rise from the earth, and water the whole face of the ground -
[2:7] then the LORD God formed man from the dust of the ground, and breathed into his nostrils the breath of life; and the man became a living being.
[2:8] And the LORD God planted a garden in Eden, in the east; and there he put the man whom he had formed.
[2:9] Out of the ground the LORD God made to grow every tree that is pleasant to the sight and good for food, the tree of life also in the midst of the garden, and the tree of the knowledge of good and evil.
[2:10] A river flows out of Eden to water the garden, and from there it divides and becomes four branches.
[2:11] The name of the first is Pishon; it is the one that flows around the whole land of Havilah, where there is gold;
[2:12] and the gold of that land is good; bdellium and onyx stone are there.
[2:13] The name of the second river is Gihon; it is the one that flows around the whole land of Cush.
[2:14] The name of the third river is Tigris, which flows east of Assyria. And the fourth river is the Euphrates.
[2:15] The LORD God took the man and put him in the garden of Eden to till it and keep it.
[2:16] And the LORD God commanded the man, "You may freely eat of every tree of the garden;
[2:17] but of the tree of the knowledge of good and evil you shall not eat, for in the day that you eat of it you shall die."
[2:18] Then the LORD God said, "It is not good that the man should be alone; I will make him a helper as his partner."
[2:19] So out of the ground the LORD God formed every animal of the field and every bird of the air, and brought them to the man to see what he would call them; and whatever the man called every living creature, that was its name.
[2:20] The man gave names to all cattle, and to the birds of the air, and to every animal of the field; but for the man there was not found a helper as his partner.
[2:21] So the LORD God caused a deep sleep to fall upon the man, and he slept; then he took one of his ribs and closed up its place with flesh.
[2:22] And the rib that the LORD God had taken from the man he made into a woman and brought her to the man.
[2:23] Then the man said, "This at last is bone of my bones and flesh of my flesh; this one shall be called Woman, for out of Man this one was taken."
[2:24] Therefore a man leaves his father and his mother and clings to his wife, and they become one flesh.
[2:25] And the man and his wife were both naked, and were not ashamed
.


In version 1, God creates heaven and earth, light and dark, water, earth, plants, the sun and stars, all the various creatures, and then humans in the form of man. First God contemplates creating humans (1:26) and giving him dominion over all other plants and animals, then God creates humans (1:27) both male and female, then wishes them to reproduce and dominate nature (1:28), and points out generally the plant and animals at their disposal, for their use (1:29-1:30).


 


Version 2 is slightly different.


Chapter 2 starts with the creation of everything existing being complete and God “resting” on the 7th day, setting aside every 7th day for rest going forward. The text then back-tracks to the moment before plants and animals and water were created (2:4), only earth and sky, and describes the creation of the first (male) human in that void (2:7), formed from the clay of the earth, with life breathed in through the nostrils. Immediately following the creation of man, God plants (2:8) a garden in a place named Eden, in the east, and places man in the garden. God then forms the plants and trees as they grow (2:9). The text then names and locates the 4 rivers which divide and irrigate the land (2:10-2:14). God again puts man in the garden (2:15), invites him to eat of all the plants and trees except one (2:15-17). God then states that it is not good that man is alone, and decides to make for him a “helper and partner.” (2:18) First, however, God creates birds and animals from the earth and brings them to man to name each. (2:19-20). God then puts man to sleep, and while he is asleep removes a rib from his side which God forms into a woman, and presents her to man (2:21-22). Man then expresses his unity with the woman, as shared flesh (2:23), and (henceforth) sets the precedent that men and women will leave their parents and untie as one.


 


There are some basic differences between the two versions, especially in the exact sequence of creation--plants, animals, humans--but those differences can be resolved by reading version 1 as a summary and version 2 as a more detailed description.


The general premises remain the same: God created all things, including humans.


The general reading suggests that humans were made fully formed as complete biological adults. There is not mention of humans being infants, or progressing through a stage of development and maturation. Immediately after creation (1:27-1:28), humans are encouraged to reproduce, so it can be assumed they already at an age of maturity, at least in their teens, when reproduction is possible.


The exclusion of reference to infancy does not necessarily preclude the possibility that humans were formed and birthed as infants (as all following humans were) and somehow nurtured by God to maturity, since God is still described as their creator, despite whatever details may be missing from the narrative. The idea that humans are God’s creation –in fact, made in God’s likeness—still holds, and this is the over-riding emphasis of the description. Nothing in the text necessarily precludes the notion that man may have developed through evolutionary processes, either, since all things existing ultimately were created by God. If the text is read as symbolic or generalized language describing everything’s existence being dependent upon God for its creation, then any number of biological possibilities are admissible, without contradiction.


If the text is read literally, as the exact method of creation of humans and all else, there are some interesting implications to consider, especially in the more detailed description of version 2. If the humans currently inhabiting the earth are the same species as these first humans, with the same basic intellectual and emotional capacities and propensities, to fully make the connection between humans today and these first humans,  one must make some conceptual leaps, it would seem, to fill in some blanks that are left unexplained in the text. As described literally, humans are formed instantly, transformed from non-existence to existence from raw material of the earth, then breathed life into by God. One must guess that included in the life-giving breath are the cognitive abilities of a fully functional adult and a base-line of understanding in order to process the incoming stimulus of the world. Transfer of these skills would likely be within the ability of the divine creator. Without such a cognitive cushioning, it would be difficult to imagine the enormity of the shock that the sudden transition from non-existence to existence must have been, especially as described in version 2, where the first human in virtually alone in the new world. (If in version 1, male and female are created simultaneously, at least there is another member of the same species with which to identify.)


As described, the first 2 humans are the first orphans. Yes, they are the creation of the all-powerful God/ creator, and it is conceivable that direct contact with the supreme being would make the emotional need of human parents unnecessary; but it is equally conceivable that fully formed humans who are asked to instantly make judgments would be at a distinct dis-advantage without being raised by and nurtured by other humans through a long period of development.


The line 2:24 is interesting in this regard. After the formation of the first woman, and the kindred unity between male and female, “Therefore a man leaves his father and his mother and clings to his wife.” This statement would apply to generations going forward, but would not apply to the first 2 humans, as they have no mother and father besides God. If there is an implication that humans would ‘leave” God who represents the first parents, this is fulfilled in short order in the story of the first sin and the expulsion from the first garden. Humans are placed in a fruitful garden and given one rule, which is to avoid partaking the fruit of one particular tree. It is assumed that these first 2 humans were fully formed mentally to make the choice either to obey this rule and avoid this fruit, or to, for whatever reason, break this first rule. Interestingly, the tree which bears this fruit is called “the tree of the knowledge of good and evil.” Of course, there is nothing about the tree as described that is inherently good or evil; it is good only by God’s rule (avoidance) or evil (by partaking of it.) It is the first test, which the first two humans fail.


As humans, with a certain intellectual capacity and possibly an inherent curiosity, it is understandable that the first humans might be interested in discovering what is meant by god and evil. They are easily seduced by that prospect, and disobey God’s first rule without apparent prolonged deliberation. Most children transgress various rules over the course of their development and learn, over time to live within certain established boundaries. Not so, the first two humans. The first rule of God is broken, and the punishment is severe. One must assume, for the sake of this narrative, that humans were given the ability to make their own choice, and thus must suffer the consequences of that choice. The text is somewhat ambiguous; we must assume that humans were equally capable of making the right choice as well as the wrong choice, and that they were not inherently flawed, thus undermining the legitimacy of the punishment (or reward if it had gone the other way.) The rule is simple and clear--avoid this tree’s fruit—but there is no reason given other than it is the first rule of God. That, of course, should be enough: the all-powerful God does not necessarily have to explain or justify the rules set forth. One is expected to obey the rules, even without explanation.


Yet, back to 2:24: “Therefore a man leaves his father and his mother and clings to his wife.” Were the first humans destined to break the first rule? If so, did they really have a true choice? Or were they truly capable of making that choice?


This tale of the original sin and expulsion can serve as the completion of the development and education of the first humans. In this story, humans gain knowledge and suffer for it. Knowledge is painful, and originates from human inability to follow the rules of God.


To look to the serpent is to complicate the matter even more, since it is often assumed that animals have no moral agency, yet this one was able to persuade one of the first humans to commit the first sin. The serpent is described as the more “crafty” of God’s creatures, and it must be assumed it was made by God deliberately as such (alone with the ability to speak the language of humans.) Again, the use of crafty seduction could be construed as part of the test, a test only meaningful if the humans were equipped to exercise free choice. God could provide the humans the capacities they needed, including the capacity to make the wrong decision.


But how severe the punishment! The tale admits the ignorance of the humans, and how easily lead astray they are. God could have chosen to make the humans more discerning, (and the serpent less crafty), or there could have been a punishment less severe that a life thereafter of toil and suffering; but this can be read as a tale of education and as an explanation for the inherent suffering and pain that often accompanies existence: this is how to connect the lives of all and current humans to the first humans, how to explain human suffering for a species once living in Eden as God’s privileged creation, with dominion over all other living things.


But so sad a tale. The sufferings of humans are self-inflicted, the creation of human failings, rather than just the natural biological tragedy of want, need, desire, longing, decay and death. The world after Eden is one without joy; even childbirth is painful, and there is endless strife and conflict.  


God could have devised things differently, but this is not the tale that is told. How lonely, too, the existence of the first humans suddenly out of nothing; without a childhood and the slow accumulation of sensation and experience that leads to knowledge if not wisdom; dropped into the world, and punished at the first error. The text is ambiguous on how long the first humans had been in Eden, before the transgression with the fruit. Time seems elastic, mythically long, yet the time in Eden does not seem long: There is no real description of  prolonged life there before the appearance of the serpent in 3:1.


Would God have preferred the first humans exist in obedient ignorance if they had not been tempted by the serpent?  Would their reward have been to remain in Eden in proximity to God forever, or would there have been a series of tests, possibly endless, to assure their fortitude? It’s possible there had been, and the serpent’s tale—the one they failed—was only the most noteworthy.


And the most tragic. Humanity, after the fall, carries with it the memory, however faint, of the paradise lost, of the ill-defined time before sin (and knowledge). Current existence is always lesser that what had been, so long ago and lost: there is no return.


Eden could be interpreted as a substitute for the womb, a place of nurturing comfort where all human needs are met; there may be some level of primordial post-partum memory in all people, that longs for that comfort that can never be fully recaptured.


By contrast, evolutionary theory of human development seems re-assuring. In that scenario, humans are part of a larger biological development, surrounded by and integrated to the wider natural environment, their own species and their tribal identity. Because humans are distinctly vulnerable at birth and could not survive long without the nurturing and support of others, each human life is integrated into a larger system which sustains them. Through their long process of maturation humans learn the skills to survive, relayed through a combination of parental and tribal guidance. Knowledge, folklore and social tradition are shared from one generation to another. This includes the moral precepts each culture develops for behavior within the tribe. In this way, a person is immersed into a larger culture from birth. The person learns the rules and customs of the society over time, gradually, with maturation. Slowly, a person learns the rules of acceptable behavior, and these are usually in accordance with the thriving of the interests of the larger tribe or group; behaviors which run counter to the over-all interests of the larger tribe are generally sanctioned. Ethics are largely socially defined, as determined in the best interest of the larger tribe.


The evolutionary model suggests a certain physical vulnerability to the human species which is compensated for by its cognitive strength. Humans are weak, small and slow compared to many of the other animals with which they compete for food and water resources. The selection that allowed upright standing and walking and the development of hands capable of complex manipulations of objects gave humans the ability to fashion tools far beyond the physical capacity of other animals, giving them the ability to dominate nature through manipulation. Primates in general are social creatures, as are many other species, and humans are no exception. Survival for humans often depended upon cooperative coordination to “out-smart” would-be competitors; like many other animals, humans are likely more successful hunters in groups than as isolated individuals, where their physical limitations could put them at a distinct disadvantage compared to other animals. A social ethos which values the success of the larger tribe rather than simply individual interests would help ensure mutual survival. Successful reproduction would include the ability to care for the incredibly vulnerable human infants, a burden which is often shared with the larger tribe in providing food, shelter, nurture.


Gone from the evolutionary model is the notion of “original sin,” and the guilt associated with the expulsion from paradise. Not that primitive humans and other primates did probably not experience fear of their surroundings and other creatures; but that fear could be tempered by understanding: myth-making is a pre-scientific way for humans to understand and explain the world, and thus attain a certain mastery over it. Nowhere in the evolutionary model does there exist an inherent flaw in human nature, some original transgression for which all humanity must pay the price. What “flaws” exist in nature—weaknesses that do not contribute to a species survival—are gradually eliminated by natural selection. Adaptations are made so that only characteristics that promote survival are retained, or the species fails to successfully reproduce and eventually becomes extinct. There is no way of knowing the emotional life of early humans, their levels of fear, guilt, happiness, fulfillment, neurosis. Biologically identical to us, it seems plausible that they would have the ability to experience the same range of emotions as any modern human, though without the intellectual development that comes from thousands of years of human civilization. But without the intellectual framework with which we order our world, it is also possible that to assume comparable modern emotions on earlier man is a mere projection: again, we cannot know how early humans “felt” any more than what they “thought.”


As we cannot know how the Biblical first man and woman felt or thought. Yet, we are told in that narrative that they were fully formed as humans, no different from modern man. In fact, there are no distinctions of time per se in this account: humans appear from non-existence suddenly, and what follows that appearance is a chain of events that lead to now. But the first biblical humans are fully human, and are immediately given tasks to function as humans, naming all the other creatures. The first act of humans is thus related to language (which?), an ability (language), like any others named or unnamed, imbued into humans through the breath of life. The first test of humans—the injunction to not eat of a certain fruit—assumes the cognitive ability for humans to make a reasonable choice. The choice made by humans, to eat the apple, cannot be characterized as irrational. Besides the inducements of the deceitful serpent, the humans decided to eat the apple, even though forbidden to do so. Not only did the fruit look delicious, but they were convinced that eating it “would make them wise.” Thus, the “tree of knowledge” feeds both physical and mental hunger, the human’s primal quest for understanding beyond their base biological need for food. Eating of the fruit was not a random or thoughtless act; it was considered, and the benefits (knowledge) we concluded to outweight risks; one had no way of knowing (literally) the consequences that might come from dis-obeying the direct edict of God. It would be supposed that it would not be advisable to defy God in any way, but without knowledge, how would one know the consequence? Thus the first humans are said to have the cognitive ability to rationally choose, but no knowledge with which to base that cognition: cognition without knowledge.


If the first humans had decided not to eat of the fruit, despite the temptation, they would never have known the consequences of defying the will of God (which were severe.) They would, in fact, not have knowledge or wisdom. They would live eternally in ignorant innocence. Would there be no progress, then, no history, no civilization? Humans happy, un-ashamed together in paradise forever? This does not then explain the “human condition,” the world we find ourselves in: one filled with joys and happiness as well as suffering and death, struggle and un-happiness.


Certainly, other myths could have created a narrative to explain our present state, good and bad; but there was almost no choice in this first narrative: humans had to defy God in search of knowledge.


They were punished for it.


Their first moment of understanding is followed by shame, or at least confusion:


[3:6] So when the woman saw that the tree was good for food, and that it was a delight to the eyes, and that the tree was to be desired to make one wise, she took of its fruit and ate; and she also gave some to her husband, who was with her, and he ate.
[3:7] Then the eyes of both were opened, and they knew that they were naked; and they sewed fig leaves together and made loincloths for themselves.
This recognition of their nakedness is appears as almost spontaneous, not specifically mandated by God. Why it would follow that covering the areas of gender difference as the immediate response to this recognition is not fully explained (as if no explanation was needed, though this hints at being of a later morality transposed back in time to the dawn of humanity.) There follows a curious passage of narrative:


[3:8] They heard the sound of the LORD God walking in the garden at the time of the evening breeze, and the man and his wife hid themselves from the presence of the LORD God among the trees of the garden.


God is given a terrestrial embodiment, out for an evening stroll, gendered as male.
[3:9] But the LORD God called to the man, and said to him,"Where are you?"


Surely simply a test, since God, as an omnipotent being, knows all, including the location of his creations.
[3:10] He said, "I heard the sound of you in the garden, and I was afraid, because I was naked; and I hid myself."
[3:11] He said, "Who told you that you were naked? Have you eaten from the tree of which I commanded you not to eat?"


Again a test, since God, as an omnipotent being, knows all, including the answer to his own questions.


The implications in this exchange are that before the act of disobedience of Gods first law, the first humans were naked but unaware and un-ashamed of their nudity. One can surmise that their state was simply a part of the natural order of life in the primordial garden. In that state of pre-sin, the first humans recognized the sexual differences between themselves to “leave(s) his father and his mother and clings to his wife, and they become one flesh”. If they had not sinned by breaking the first rule of God, it was possible that the first humans could have existed indefinitely in naked ignorance. But the first transgression leads to a rupture in that benign innocence of sexual difference.
[3:12] The man said, "The woman whom you gave to be with me, she gave me fruit from the tree, and I ate."


Curiously, the first man does not answer simply “yes, I ate the fruit,” nor does he attempt to protect the first woman, or explain her transgressions, instead immediately deflects his own blame to her.
[3:13] Then the LORD God said to the woman, "What is this that you have done?" The woman said, "The serpent tricked me, and I ate."


Like her male counterpart, the first woman attempts to mitigate blame by saying she was tricked by another, even while admitting her actions forthrightly.
[3:14] The LORD God said to the serpent, "Because you have done this, cursed are you among all animals and among all wild creatures; upon your belly you shall go, and dust you shall eat all the days of your life.


In an abrupt change from this line to the next God has stopped talking to the serpent and is addressing the first humans:
[3:15] I will put enmity between you and the woman, and between your offspring and hers; he will strike your head, and you will strike his heel."


Thus, the harmony of ignorance before the first sin is shattered and male and woman are condemned to live in enmity. This, along with the recognition of their nakedness, renders (seemingly forever) the gender differences so basic to natural life not as a harmonious part of a whole system, but in conflict and strife. Was this strife dormant in the first humans before eating the apple, or did this only arise after eating the forbidden fruit. One of the first acts of humans, expressed in their witness before God on question, was that of betrayal. Technically, the man describes his actions truthfully-- "The woman whom you gave to be with me, she gave me fruit from the tree, and I ate." –but the implication lingers that woman was the first to break the rule of God and he simply followed. The story describing the eating of the fruit, however, states explicitly that he was with the woman when she ate the fruit: she took of its fruit and ate; and she also gave some to her husband, who was with her, and he ate. Absent is any hesitation on the part of the male, or sense of caution. He could not claim ignorance of what they were doing, yet he points out to God that it was the woman who gave him the forbidden fruit. Likewise, the woman states only in her defense that she had been tricked by the serpent. Nothing the humans said to God was un-true: neither tried to deny their crime outright, not protect the only other human in existence in the face of God. If both humans faced a test of their allegiance at that moment of questioning between God—by admitting their action—or humans—by somehow trying to protect each other from God—they affirmed their allegiance to God by admitting their actions, and not trying to protect themselves. God, in his initial admonition to them to avoid the forbidden tree, had warned that “you shall die” if they had any contact with the tree or its fruit. The man and woman were aware of serious consequences of breaching God’s law.


            Sadly, the first man does implicate the first woman and does not protect her when confronted by God. Telling the truth to God is given no credit by God, after the crime of their explicit disobedience of his first law. Would man have betrayed the woman in another circumstance, before the taking of the fruit, in their period of innocent Eden, or was this callous behavior toward her a consequence of first crime and sin? Were human made by God to be selfish in their need for self-preservation, or was that tendency a result of their disobedience of God? Certainly, the initial punishment God gives to the first humans, man and woman alike, is severe: a break of the previous unity of man and woman, with an enmity between them. Was the Man’s mentioning of the Woman’s role in the crime the first expression of that enmity, even before expressly stated by God? If the characters of the first humans were fully shaped before eating the forbidden fruit, as is assumed, then the seeds of that enmity, though dormant, were instilled by God at creation. If humans were less that fully formed in all ways, they could not be called upon to follow the rules of God except by blind, un-thinking obedience.


            Despite God’s warning to the first humans that “you shall die” if they ate the fruit or touched the tree—capital punishment not, apparently a sufficient deterrent to prevent the crime—God does not in fact kill either of them immediately. Each is given their own form of punishment, for the woman pain, for the man, toil:
[3:16] To the woman he said, "I will greatly increase your pangs in childbearing; in pain you shall bring forth children, yet your desire shall be for your husband, and he shall rule over you."
[3:17] And to the man he said, "Because you have listened to the voice of your wife, and have eaten of the tree about which I commanded you, 'You shall not eat of it,' cursed is the ground because of you; in toil you shall eat of it all the days of your life;
[3:18] thorns and thistles it shall bring forth for you; and you shall eat the plants of the field.

[3:19] By the sweat of your face you shall eat bread until you return to the ground,


God reinforces the enmity between humans with the preface to the man: "Because you have listened to the voice of your wife, and have eaten of the tree..” Rather than say simply “because you have disobeyed me,” there is the added layer of interpretation that part of the crime of disobedience comes from both listening to another human in opposition to God’s dictates, and listening to a woman specifically. Once can speculate if the second human had been another male instead of a woman, would there still be the call against listening to him who led them astray, or is there a special offence by the fact that the second human is a woman and not a man. Women are defined from creation as a helper as his partner; while the word partner may imply equal status, the word helper implies a slightly secondary status: the man (first human creature) as the primary example of the new species, with the second human assisting the first in whatever endeavors the first instigates. Even if the second human is physically formed partially from the flesh of the first-- the rib that the LORD God had taken from the man he made into a woman—she is not considered the first man’s child, is recognized by the first man as flesh of my flesh and man clings to his wife, and they become one flesh.
Still there is some ambiguity to her status as equal or slightly less than equal then the first human. The fact that it is the second human and not the first who is tempted into disobedience complicates the matter somewhat further. Is her status diminished by that act? Are women not therefore to be listened to? Or is that curious phrase more general, as an admonition to listen to any other human in opposition to God, regardless of sex? There is the implication that in that moment when the man listened to the voice of (his) wife, it represented a conscious choice of being influenced by humans rather than God. In that moment, humans act as fully autonomous creatures, separate from God, capable of either following his rules or not; this moment, then, represents the full realization of their humanity as independent thoughtful agents. This may be their true crime, as God hints at further when he explains
[3:22] Then the LORD God said, "See, the man has become like one of us, knowing good and evil;


The acquisition of knowledge is on par with human desire to become God, the ultimate hubris. Quite curious is the phrasing like one of us, rather than like me, implying not only that there is more than one God, but that the story God is telling is directed at other Gods; there are others- like one of us—who know good and evil: who are these others? How did they acquire this knowledge?  This hint of the existence of other gods is not inconsistent with other Biblical texts, which refer obliquely to the existence of other gods, while insisting that this one is the supreme one, worthy of worship and obedience. This insistence becomes the defining rule of God, which supersedes all others.


            For breaking the first rule, God banishes the first humans from the primordial garden.
[3:23] therefore the LORD God sent him forth from the garden of Eden, to till the ground from which he was taken.
[3:24] He drove out the man; and at the east of the garden of Eden he placed the cherubim, and a sword flaming and turning to guard the way to the tree of life.


            To explain or understand the nature of modern human suffering, the first humans had to have left the first garden of harmony. They could not have lived in the garden in eternal harmony and ended up is the world we inhabit today. Since time is vague in these early passages, it is hard to guess how long between their own creation and their expulsion were the first humans in the garden. No other actions are described after the creation of woman besides the eating of the fruit; since there is no reference to the passage of time, or life in Eden before the fall, it almost seems as if eating the fruit was the first, or one of the first, acts done by humans. This may be simply narrative prudence, since there is such an epic tale to tell in the following thousands of pages. There might indeed have been a great deal of time spent in Eden, but that time is not described.


But Eden could not have simply fallen into natural decay; that would have implied an imperfection in God’s creation. Nor could it have decayed through neglect, since that would imply indifference on the part of a paternalistic, caring God. Since imperfections cannot be associated with God, humans must be responsible for their own fate, good or bad. God could have chosen to make them more obedient, wise or intelligent creatures, but for reasons unknown, chose not to.


Yet, despite the threat before the taking of the fruit that “you shall die” if you take of it, the first humans were not killed; the first man lived to be nine hundred thirty years [5:5], an oddly specific number. (It is unclear how long the first woman lived. She is not referred to again in the Bilbical text, besides in passing reference to being mother of the first man’s children). Their lives, it is assumed, were filled with toil and sorrow. Again, time may be measured in a different way than is done in modern times: certainly living nine hundred years does not seem biologically plausible, if years are measured as modern man measures them. Still, a long life.


Nothing is said about how that life was lived by the first man and woman all those many years. They have 2 children, Abel and Cain, and later when the first man is 130 years old, another son Seth, as well as other sons and daughters, un-named. Seth lived 912 years, fathering a child, Enosh, when he was 105. Enosh lived 905 years, fathering a child, Kenan, when he was 90; Kenan lived 910 years, fathering a child, Mahalalel when he was 70; Mahalalel lived 895 years, fathering a child, Jared, when he was 65; Jared lived 962 years, fathering a child, Enoch when he was 162; Enoch lived 365 years, fathering a child, Methuselah, when he was 65; Methuselah lived 969 years, fathering a child, Lamech, when he was 187; Lamech lived 777 years, fathering a child, Noah, when he was 182, along with other children, un-named.[5:1-5:32]. Noah lived 950 years. If Seth was born when the first man (Adam) was 130 years old, the total years elapsed until the time of Noah’s death comes to 2006. Because of the extraordinary longevity of these early peoples, only 126 years separated Noah’s birth from Adam’s death. Adam would have lived to see the birth of great, great, great, great, great, great, great, grandchild. Adam’s grandchild Enosh—son of Adam/s third son Seth—and all the generations after him until Noah (save Enoch who lived, oddly and specifically only 365 years compared to the others who lived on average 900+ years) would have been alive in Noah’s lifetime. Again, these could not be counted as biological years as we know them today. Only a few rare living things, trees among them, live that long on the earth as is known. If the first humans were in every way biologically identical to modern people, this longevity, as well as their ability to reproduce successfully at age 130, defies understanding. The natural order described would defy the systems which has been observed and understood in modern times. The Biblical text suggests the creation of all things whole, including, presumably, the systems and principles by which it is ordered that science has been struggling for hundreds of years to discover and understand. Knowing what we do about human growth and aging at present times, it is impossible to contemplate humans existing for hundreds of years, let alone close to 1000 years. Were they in good health during most of those years, robust and vigorous?


If life after Eden was one of struggle and toil, the longevity is even more extraordinary. But maybe that longevity was part of the punishment of disobeying God’s law. Despite the warning that they would be killed for disobedience, the first humans are condemned to very long life of suffering. The text is silent on the actual quality of the long lives of the first humans after Eden; it is impossible to know the amount of happiness or sorrow that filled their lives, though it is implied that happiness was unlikely. Adam, in his long lifetime would have been alive during at least two murders, the first the death of his second son by his first, and later a murder by one of his grandchildren (Lemech) of a person unknown [4:23]. It is suggested that Adam and Eve knew of Abel’s death, and conceived of their third child Seth, in the words of Eve: “God has appointed for me another child instead of Abel, because Cain killed him,” [4:25]  which shows clearly her recognition of Abel’s death, though there is no other reaction associated with that fact.


By the time of Noah’s birth, God has become so disappointed in his human creations that “[6:6] … the LORD was sorry that he had made humankind on the earth, and it grieved him to his heart,” despite the fact that it had earlier been described that  [5:1]… When God created humankind, he made them in the likeness of God.
[5:2] ….and he blessed them…
Yet, after roughly 2000 years of human existence, [6:5] The LORD saw that the wickedness of humankind was great in the earth, and that every inclination of the thoughts of their hearts was only evil continually. So bad, apparently had the situation on earth become that God decided to destroy all of his creation and start anew. This is quite an extraordinary failure, for which, it would seem, God bears some great responsibility for creating such flawed creatures, as any parent may bear some responsibility, however remote, for the actions and character of their children. Did Adam and Eve feel sorrow for the lives lived by their first two children? God, given the attribute of a heart by which to grieve, seems to bear no responsibility for how his creations were progressing, since they were the ones who had disobeyed him. Yet, the first humans had to leave the garden, whether by sin or other means, to reach the world that exists today. God could have simply decided to close the garden and send his human family off into a different world more similar to our own; but that is not the story that is told. The fault is in humans, even if it could not have been any other way.


The lives of the first humans in the evolutionary model are also lost to us, for the most part, though we are slowly piecing together evidence that give hints of their customs, art and culture. We can follow a trail of evidence that sees the migration of the first humans out of Africa and spreading to all corners of the planet, of the shift from hunting and gathering to fixed agriculture and settled communities, to the development of complex societies and social structures. Some theorize that the decisive moment in human development was precisely that shift from hunting and gathering to agriculture, since it is with that shift that ideas develop that are still with us today, including ownership of private property (land), hierarchical social structures and un-equal distribution of resources, nation-state. For all the benefits associated with settled agricultural communities, is there hidden within humans, a nostalgic longing for the time before, the time of plenty in the African Eden? Is the Biblical version simply tapping into that deep-seated, hidden memory? Oddly, the time immediately before the flood which Noah survived, is described as the time when The Nephilim [giants] were on the earth in those days [6:4]; these, and their off-spring are destroyed in the great flood. Is this a veiled reference the dinosaurs which preceded humans as the dominant creature on the planet? Is the flood a reference to one of the many mass extinctions which have befallen our planet, and led to the development of man? Are those great extinctions hidden in some deep recess of human memory, even if the most recent to human times occurred 66 million years before? Or had early humans stumbled upon some of the same evidence modern science is now analyzing, and come up with its own explanation? Likewise, is the story of the murder of Abel by Cain a reference to the displacement (and possible murder) of the Neanderthals by modern humans to attain supremacy as the dominant  primate species? Is this the great crime that lurks in the human past, to which the Biblical text refers, with poetic embellishment?


            We cannot fully know the lives of the first humans, based on the scattered evidence that exists; we cannot know their capacity for ethical behavior and rational thought, though both must have been equal to our own, since we are identical creatures. Cooperation and compassion are evolutionarily useful for survival, and settled agriculture and the building of cities requires a degree of cooperation. Certainly, known human history is replete with examples of seemingly insatiable capacity for cruel and selfish behavior by humans. These behaviors never cease to shock our sensibilities, but they shock, in part, because of the equally numerous examples of human compassion and kindness that populate our history. Humans may be deeply flawed creatures, unable, often to make good decisions or even act in their own self-interest. Balancing non-rational and rational thought—emotion and reason—is a basic human challenge, but our enhanced ability at rational thought is what distinguishes us from other animals more reliant on emotive cognition. It is our ability to analyze our non-rational impulses—good or bad—which offers humans a key to survival in the highly competitive natural world. Knowledge is not a crime. Even in the Biblical tale, humans seemed to inherently understand that. The flaws God seems to perceive in his human creations lie, ultimately, not with them, but within their flawed creator, God. Humans are far from perfect, but there are no perfect creatures; all living things have survived after a long process of development that will continue into the future, to be superseded by other generations of living things, in a great continuum of time and space. There is an assured stability in this ongoing flux, as life marches on following its own natural order, seeking its own perfection, its own survival rather than being dependent upon the arbitrary whims of a mercurial, flawed and often hostile God.