“The sun had been covered up; snow was beginning to fall. It
was sprinkled over the black pores of the gravel and was lying in thin slips on
the slanting roofs. I could see a long way from the third floor height. Not far
off there were chimneys, their smoke a lighter grey than the grey of the sky;
and, straight before me, ranges of poor dwellings, warehouses, billboards,
culverts, electric signs blankly burning, parked cars and moving cards, and the
occasional bare plane of a tree. These I surveyed, pressing my forehead on the
glass. It was my painful obligation to look and to submit to myself the
invariable question: Where was there a particle of what, elsewhere, or in the
past, had spoken in man’s favor? There could be no doubt that these billboards,
streets, tracks, houses, ugly and blind, were related to interior life. And
yet, I told myself, there had to be a doubt. There were human lives organized
around these ways and houses and that they, the houses, say, were analogue,
that what men created they also were, through some transcendent means, I could
not bring myself to concede. There must be a difference, a quality that eluded
me, somehow, a difference between things and persons and even between acts and
persons. Otherwise the people who lived here were actually a reflection of the
things they lived among. I had always striven to avoid blaming them. Was that
not the effect behind my daily reading of the paper? In their business and
politics, their taverns, movies, assaults, divorces, murders, I tried continuously
to find clear signs of their common humanity.
It was
undeniably to my interest to do this. Because I was involved with them: because
weather I liked it or not, they were my generation, my society, my world. We
were figures in the same plot, eternally fixed together. I was aware, also that
their existence, just as it was, made mine possible. And if, as was often said,
this part of the century was approaching the nether curve in a cycle, then I
too would remain on the bottom and there, extinct, merely add my body, my life,
to the base of a coming time. This would probably be a condemned age. But…it
might be a mistake to think of it in that way. Mists faded and spread and faded
on the plane as I breathed. Perhaps a mistake. And when I thought of the condemned
ages ad those unnamed, lying in their obscurity, I wondered…how do we know how
it was? In all principal ways the human spirit must have been the same. Good
apparently left few traces. And we are coming to know that had misjudged whole
epochs. Besides, the giants of the last century had their Liverpools and
Londons, their Lilles and Hamburgs to contend against, as we have our Chicagos
and Detroits. And there might be a chance that I was misled, even with these
ruins before my eyes, sodden, themselves the color of the fateful paper that I
read daily…The worlds we sought were never those we saw; the worlds we
bargained for were never the worlds we got.
I have
spoken of an “invariable question.” But the fact is that it had for many months
been not in the least invariable. These were things I would have thought last
winter, and now, in their troubled density, they served only to remind me of
the sort of person I had been. For a long time “common humanity” and “bring
myself to concede” had been completely absent from my mind. And all at once I
saw how I had lapsed from the older self to whom they had been so natural.”
Bellow, Dangling Man P 17-18
“Theories of wholly good or wholly malevolent world strike
him as foolish. Of those who believe in a wholly good world he says that they
do not understand depravity. As for pessimists, the question he asks of them
is, “Is that all they see, such people?” For him, the world is both, and
therefore neither. Merely to make a judgment of that kind is, to representatives
of either position, a satisfaction. Whereas to him, judgment is second to
wonder, to speculation on men, drugged and clear, jealous, ambitious, good
tempered, curious, each in his own time and with his customs and motives, and
bearing the imprint of strangeness of the world. In a sense, everything is good
because it exists. Or, good or not, it is ineffable, and, for that reason,
marvelous.
“But for
all of that, joseph suffers from a feeling of strangeness, of not quite
belonging to the world, of lying under a cloud and looking up at it. Now, he
says, all human beings are this to some extent. The child feels that his
parents are pretenders; his real father is elsewhere and will someday come to
claim him. And for others the real world is not here at all and what is at hand
is spurious and copied. Joseph’s feeling od strangeness sometimes takes the
form almost of conspiracy: not a conspiracy of evil, but one which contains the
diversified splendors, the shifts, excitements and also the common, neutral matter
of an existence. Living from day to day under the shadow of such a conspiracy
is trying. It makes for wonder, it makes even more for un-easiness, and one
clings to the nearest passer-by, to brothers, parents, friends, and wives.”
Bellow, Dangling Man P 20-21
“He had asked himself a question I still would like
answered, namely, “how should a good man live; what ought he to do?” Hence the
plans. Unfortunately, most of them were foolish. Also they led him to be untrue
to himself. He made mistakes of the sort people make who see things as they
wish to see them or, for the sake of their plans, must see them. There might be
some justice in the view that man was born the slayer of his father and of his
brother, full of instinctive bloody rages, licentious and unruly from his
earliest days, an animal who had to be tamed. But he protested, he could find
in himself no such history of hate overcome. He could not. He believed in his
own mildness, believed in it piously. He allowed this belief to interfere with
his natural shrewdness and did both himself and his friends a disservice. They
could not give him what he wanted.
“What he
wanted was a “colony of the spirit,” or a group whose covenants forbade spite,
bloodiness, and cruelty. To hack, to tear, to murder was for those in whom the
sense of the temporariness of life had shrunk. The world was crude and it was
dangerous and, if no measures were taken, existence could indeed become—in
Hobbes’ phrase, which had long ago lodged in Joseph’s mind—‘nasty, brutish,
short.’ It need not become so if a number of others would combine to defend
themselves against danger and crudity.”
Bellow, Dangling Man P 27
“…I was still an apprentice in suffering and humiliation. I
had not even begun. I had, furthermore, no right to expect to avoid them. So
much was immediately clear. Surely no one could plead for exception; that was
not a human privilege. What I should do with them, how to meet them, was
answered in the second declaration: with grace, without meanness. And though I
could not as yet apply that answer to myself, I recognized its rightness and
was vehemently moved by it. Not until I was a whole man could it be my answer,
too. And was I to become this whole man alone, without aid? I was too weak for
it, I did not command the will. Then in what quarter would I look for help,
where was the power? Grace, by what law, under what order, by whom required?
Personal, human, or universal, was it? The music named only one source, the
universal one, God. But what a miserable surrender that would be, born out of
disheartenment and chaos; ad out of fear, bodily and imperious, that like a
disease, asked for a remedy and did not care how it was supplied….No, not God,
not any divinity. That was anterior, not of my own deriving. I was not so full of
pride that I could not accept the existence of something greater than myself,
something, perhaps, of which I was an idea, or merely a fraction of an idea.
That was not it. But I did not want to catch at any contrivance in panic. In my
eyes, that was a great crime….But was there no way to attain that answer except
to sacrifice the mind that sought to be satisfied? From the antidote itself
another disease would spring. It was not a new matter, it was one that I had
frequently considered. But not with such a desperate emotion or such a crucial
need for an answer. Or such a feeling of loneliness. Out of my own strength it
was necessary for me to return the verdict for reason, in its partial
inadequacy, and against the advantages of its surrender.”
Bellow, Dangling Man P 45-46
“Of course we suffer from bottomless avidity. Our lives are
so precious to us, we are so watchful of waste. Or perhaps a better name for it
would be the Sense of Personal Destiny. Yes, I think it is better than avidity.
Shall my life by one-thousandth of an inch fall short of its ultimate
possibility? It is a different thing to value oneself, and to prize oneself
crazily. And then there are our plans, idealizations. These are dangerous, too.
They can consume us like parasites, eat us, drink us, and leave us lifelessly
prostrate. And yet we are always inviting the parasite, as if we were eager to
be drained and eaten.
It is
because we are taught there is no limit to what a man can be. Six hundred years
ago, a man was what he was born to be. Satan and the church, representing God,
did battle over him. He, by reason of his choice, partially decided the
outcome. But whether, after life, he went to hell or heaven, his place among
other men was a given. It could not be contested. But, since, the stage had
been reset and human beings only walk on it, and under this revision we have,
instead, history to answer to. We were important enough then for our souls to
be fought over. Now each of us is responsible for his own salvation, which is
in his greatness. And that, that greatness, is the rock our hearts are abraded
on. Great minds, great beauties, great lovers and criminals surround us. From
such great sadness and desperation of Werthers and Don Juans we went to the
great ruling images of napoleons; from these to murderers who had that right
over victims because they were greater than their victims; to men who felt
privileged to approach others with a whip; to schoolboys and clerks who roared
like revolutionary lions; to those pimps and subway creatures, debater in
midnight cafeterias who believed they could be great in treachery and catch the
throats of those they felt were sound and well in the lassos of their
morbidity; to dream of great beautiful shadows embracing on a flawless screen.
Because of these things we hate immoderately and punish ourselves and one
another immoderately. The fear of lagging pursues and maddens us. The fear lies
in us like a cloud. It makes an inner climate of darkness. And occasionally
there is a storm and hate and wounding rain out of us.”
Bellow, Dangling Man P 59-60
“great pressure is brought to bear to make us undervalue
ourselves. On the other hand, civilization teaches us that each of us is an
inestimable prize. There are, then, these two preparations: one for life and
the other for death. Therefore we value and are ashamed to value ourselves, are
hard-boiled. We are schooled in quietness and if one of us takes his measure occasionally,
he does so coolly, as if he were examining his fingernails, not his soul,
frowning at the imperfections he finds as one would at a chip or a bit of dirt.
Because, of course, we are called upon to accept the imposition of all kinds of
wrongs, to wait in ranks under a hot sun, to run up a clattering beach, to be
sentries, scouts or workingmen, to be those in the train when it is blown up, or
those at the gates when they are locked, to be of no significance, to die. The
result is that we learn to be unfeeling toward ourselves and incurious. Who can
be the earnest huntsman of himself when he knows he is in turn a quarry? Or
nothing so distinctive as quarry, but one of a shoal, driven toward the weirs.”
Bellow, Dangling Man P 79
“…But toward morning I have a way, also, of holding court on
myself, and that is even more intolerable. Half-conscious, I call in a variety
testimony on my case and am confronted by the wrongs, errors, lies, disgraces,
and the fears of a lifetime. I am forced to pass judgment on myself and to ask
question I would far rather not ask: “What is this for?” and “What am I for?”
and “Am I made for this?’ My beliefs are inadequate, they do not guard me. I
think invariably of the awning of the store on the corner. It gives as much protection
against rain and wind as my beliefs give against the chaos I am forced to face.
“God does not love those who are unable to sleep soundly,” runs an old saying.
In the morning I dress up and go about my “business.” I pass one more day no
different from the others. Night comes and I have to face another session of
sleep—that “sinister adventure” Baudelaire calls it—and be brought back to
wakefulness by degrees through a nightmare or reckoning or inventory, my mind
flapping like a rag on a clothesline in cold wind.”
Bellow, Dangling Man P 82
“There’s a lot of talk about
alienation. It’s a fool’s plea.”
“Is it?”
“You can divorce your wife or
abandon your child, but what can you do with yourself?”
“You can’t banish the world by
decree if it’s in you. Is that it, Joseph?”
“How can you? You have gone to its
schools and seen its movies and listened to its radios, read its magazines.
What if you declare you are alienated, you say you reject the Hollywood dream,
the soap opera, the cheep thriller? The denial implicates you.”
“You can decide that you want to
forget these things.”
“The world comes after you. It
presents you with a gun or a mechanic’s tool, it singles you out for this part
or that, brings you ringing news of disasters and victories, shunts you back
and forth, abridges your rights, cuts off your future, is clumsy or crafty,
oppressive, treacherous, murderous, black, whorish, venal, inadvertently naïve
or funny. Whatever you do, you cannot dismiss it.”
“What then?”
“The failing may be in us, in me. A
weakness of vision.”
“Aren’t you asking too much of
yourself?”
Bellow, Dangling Man P 91