
“The Koran is the holy book about
whose compositional process we know the most. There were at least two
mediations between the whole and the book: Mohammed listened to the word of
Allah and dictated, in his turn, to his scribes. Once—the biographers of the
Prophet tell us—while dictating to the scribe Abdullah, Mohammed left a
sentence half finished. The scribe, instinctively, suggested the conclusion. Absently,
the Prophet accepted as the divine word what Abdullah had said. This
scandalized the scribe, who abandoned the Prophet and lost his faith.
He was wrong.
The organization of the sentence, finally, was a responsibility that lay with
him: he was the one who had to deal with the internal coherence of the written
language, with grammar and syntax, to channel into it the fluidity of a thought that expands outside all language
before it becomes word, and of a word particularly fluid like that of a
prophet. The scribe’s collaboration was necessary to Allah, once he had decided
to express himself in a written text. Mohammed knew this, and allowed the
scribe the privilege of concluding sentences; but Abdullah was unaware of the
powers vested in him. He lost his faith in Allah because he lacked faith in
writing and in himself as an agent of writing.
If an
infidel were allowed to excogitate variants on the legends of the Prophet, I
would venture this one: Abdullah loses his faith because in writing under
dictation he makes a mistake and Mohammed, though he notices it, decides not to
correct it, finding the mistaken form preferable. In this case, too, Abdullah
would be wrong to be scandalized. It is on the page, not before, that the word,
even that of the prophet raptus, becomes definitive, that is to say, becomes
writing. It is only through the confining act of writing that the immensity of
the nonwritten becomes legible, that is, through the uncertainties of spelling,
the occasional lapses, oversights, unchecked leaps of word and pen. Otherwise what
is outside of us should not insist on communicating through the word, spoken or
written: let it send its messages by other paths.”
Calvino, If on a Winter’s Night, a Traveler, P182-183
No comments:
Post a Comment